Custom Cake Toppers

Roderick Carey
10 min readJun 18, 2024

--

Welcome to our roundup of the best custom cake toppers available online! From personalized designs to unique shapes, these toppers add a special touch to any cake. Let’s dive into our list and discover the perfect custom cake topper for your next celebration.

The Top 7 Best Custom Cake Toppers

  1. Customizable Edible Image Cupcake Toppers — Transform your cupcakes and cookies into edible masterpieces with this easy-to-use, customizable, and visually appealing logo edible frosting sheet!
  2. Custom Edible Photo Cake Topper Set — Transform your cakes and cupcakes into artistic masterpieces with the Decopac Create Your Own Custom Edible Cake Topper, featuring gluten-free, soy-free, and trans-fat-free ingredients for everyone’s enjoyment.
  3. Personalized Edible Photo Birthday Cake Topper — Customize your Birthday Cake Decorations with a Personalized Edible Image Cake Topper: An Attractive, Easy, and Delicious Option for a Masterpiece Creation!
  4. Personalized Custom Cake Toppers for Birthdays from A Birthday Place — Elevate your celebrations with this personalized Skyrim Dragon Elder Scrolls Image Photo Cake Topper, perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, and more!
  5. Customized Harry Potter Cake Topper for Birthday Celebrations — Bring magic to your birthday cakes with these unique and personalized Harry Potter Edible Cake Toppers, perfect for any wizard-themed event!
  6. Personalized Birthday Cake Topper for Anniversary and Baby Shower — Celebrate your unique personality with a beautifully handcrafted and durable Personalized Happy Birthday Name Cake Topper from Luxtomi, crafted for countless occasions with flawless craftsmanship and sturdiness.
  7. Retro Typewriter Wireless Mechanical Keyboard for Retro Desktop Look — Personalize your celebrations with this edible image cake topper, featuring vibrant colors, high-quality food-grade ink, and easy application for a one-of-a-kind cake experience.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ we receive compensation through qualified purchases at no cost to you!

Reviews

Customizable Edible Image Cupcake Toppers

I’ve been using these edible photo logo custom edible frosting sheets for my cupcake toppers, and I must say it adds a whole new level of fun to my baking. The images are vibrant and clear, and the frosting sheet is easy to handle. I appreciate that you can choose from a variety of colors, and even though it may take a little trial and error to get the hang of it, it’s quite simple once you figure it out.

One thing I noticed is that sometimes the image might not be perfectly centered, which can be a bit frustrating. But overall, this product is a great addition to my baking routine, and the end result is always a delightful surprise when people see my unique cupcake designs. I highly recommend these frosting sheets for anyone looking to add some personalization to their cupcakes or cookies!

Custom Edible Photo Cake Topper Set

The Decopac Create Your Own Custom Edible Cake Topper is the perfect solution for creating eye-catching cakes and cupcakes without breaking the bank. Designed with gluten-free, soy-free, and no known allergens ingredients, this topper is ideal for anyone with dietary restrictions. With simple instructions included, you can transform your cake creation into a professional work of art in no time.

The compact package ensures easy storage and portability, making it a must-have for any baker. Although not suitable for refrigeration, this topper’s non-refrigeration requirement keeps it ready to use whenever you need it.

Overall, this edible cake topper is a game-changer for those looking to elevate their cake decorations with minimum effort and maximum impact.

Personalized Edible Photo Birthday Cake Topper

A “Birthday Place” Photo Edible Image Cake Topper is a charming way to personalize your birthday cake. Customers have the option to add their own message at no additional charge, and the topper comes with free personalization. The edible image strips can be used on both cupcakes and cakes, making it a versatile option for cake decorations.

The cake toppers are made from high-quality edible ink that is certified kosher and printed on compressed icing sheets. The edible strips are easy to use, simply remove them from the backing and place on top of freshly iced cake or cupcakes. After 15 to 25 minutes, the edible image will blend with the frosting, giving your cake a professional look.

Customers appreciate the quick shipping time, with some receiving their orders within 3 days. However, there have been complaints about the shipping time taking too long for some customers. The cake toppers are also affordable, making it an easy and inexpensive way to make your cake look like a masterpiece. The only potential downside is that the edible images may be too small for some to add personalization. Overall, the “Birthday Place” Photo Edible Image Cake Topper is an attractive and easy-to-use option for customizing your birthday cake.

Personalized Custom Cake Toppers for Birthdays from A Birthday Place

Introducing the Skyrim Dragon The Elder Scrolls Image Photo Cake Topper Sheet, perfect for personalizing your birthday cakes or other special occasions. These cake toppers are made with high-quality materials that are approved by the FDA and certified as kosher. The sheets come in 8"x10" sizes and can fit either a 1/4 or a 1/2 sheet cake.

Customization is simple, just include your desired message in the gift box section at checkout. The sheets are easy to apply, peel the back off and place on top of your cake. Proper storage is essential to keep the sheet from drying out and cracking. These cake sheets can last up to 6 months when stored correctly. Note that colors may vary slightly depending on your screen.

Customized Harry Potter Cake Topper for Birthday Celebrations

Recently, I came across this fascinating Harry Potter Hogwarts Edible Image Cake Topper from A Birthday Place. It’s a personalized, custom creation that will make your cake topper stand out at any birthday party or special event.

The moment I peeled the back off the cake topper and placed it on my cake, it felt like I had brought the magic of Hogwarts right into my kitchen! The intricate details and vibrant colors made it look so realistic, it felt as if the broomstick was about to take flight.

However, be prepared for the fact that the colors may vary slightly depending on your screen, so it’s best to double-check when placing your order. Also, remember to store the topper in a sealed plastic bag when not in use to keep it fresh and from drying out.

In conclusion, this Harry Potter Hogwarts Edible Image Cake Topper from A Birthday Place is a unique and charming addition to any celebration. Its high-quality, personalized touch adds a whimsical touch and ensures a memorable event.

Personalized Birthday Cake Topper for Anniversary and Baby Shower

Create a personalized birthday cake topper that stands out with Luxtomi’s high-quality, handcrafted cake toppers. Made in the USA from durable fiberboard and finished with luxurious paint, these cake toppers are crafted to match your unique personality and are perfect for special occasions like anniversaries and baby showers.

With a sturdy design and easy returns or refunds, you can express your love in a truly special way with this custom cake topper.

Retro Typewriter Wireless Mechanical Keyboard for Retro Desktop Look

Create a unique and personalized touch for your loved ones’ special birthdays or retirement with these Happy Retirement Weekend Edible Image Cake Toppers. With the option to customize your message at no extra cost, these edible decorations stand out as the newest trend in cake decorating. The high-quality, food-grade ink ensures vibrant colors, while the top-tier icing sheets used provide the best results.

Simply lay the cake topper on your cake, and you’re good to go! Store the sheets in a cool, dark space, sealed in a plastic bag to maintain their quality for up to 6 months. Remember, colors may slightly vary due to screen differences, but the overall experience will be unforgettable.

Buyer’s Guide

Custom cake toppers have become a popular addition to baked goods. They provide a unique touch to any celebration cake and a personal touch that is sure to impress guests. However, with so many options available in the market, choosing the right custom cake topper can be a daunting task. To help you make an informed decision, we’ve put together this buyer’s guide that covers the most important features, considerations, and advice for custom cake toppers.

Material

One of the most important factors to consider when choosing a custom cake topper is the material it is made from. Some popular options include fondant, edible sugar paste, sculpted fondant, and gum paste. Each material has its own advantages and drawbacks, so it’s important to choose one that suits your needs.

Design

Design is another crucial aspect of custom cake toppers. You can choose from a wide range of pre-made designs, such as flowers, animals, or characters, or opt for a more personalized design featuring the recipient’s name, initials, or a special message. If you have a specific design in mind, make sure to communicate it clearly with the cake topper maker to ensure they can create the desired outcome.

Edible or Non-Edible

Custom cake toppers can be either edible or non-edible. Edible toppers are made from materials such as fondant, sugar paste, or gum paste, and are safe to eat. Non-edible toppers, on the other hand, are typically made from materials like plastic, resin, or metal, and are not meant for consumption. Choose an edible topper if you plan to serve the cake at a meal or party, and opt for a non-edible one if you plan to use it as a decoration only.

Size and Shape

Custom cake toppers come in a variety of sizes and shapes. Determine the size you need based on the size of your cake and the number of people you are serving. If you want a more realistic representation of a character, consider choosing a topper in the shape of the head or full body. Alternatively, opt for a more abstract design, like a monogram or a cake-topping shape, for a more artistic look.

FAQ

What are custom cake toppers?

Custom cake toppers are unique, personalized decorations designed and made specifically for individual cakes. They can range from simple designs to intricate, colorful, and detailed ones. Each custom cake topper is created to fulfill the specific requirements and preferences of the customer, making their cake visually stand out from others.

Custom cake toppers are perfect for special occasions, events, and celebrations, as they allow individuals to enhance the look of their cakes and showcase their creativity, brand image, or event theme through unique designs and concepts. These custom toppers can be made from various materials such as sugar paste, fondant, edible photo paper, chocolate, or even baked goods.

What types of custom cake toppers are available?

A wide variety of custom cake topppers are available in the market to cater to different needs and preferences. Some of the most common types include wedding cake topppers, baby shower cake toppers, birthday cake toppers, themed cake toppers (such as superhero, cartoon, or movie-themed), sports-themed cake toppers, and corporate cake toppers (including logo cake toppers, company branding, and promotional cake toppers).

Further, custom toppers can be made using various materials like fondant, edible printed paper, plastic, silicone, sugar paste, chocolate, and baked goods. The material selection depends on the specific requirements, durability, and aesthetic preference of the customer. Some toppers can even be made edible or inedible, depending on the intended use and desired presentation quality.

What makes custom cake toppers unique?

Custom cake toppers are unique because they are designed to the customer’s specifications, reflecting their theme, preferences, brand, or event. Unlike pre-made toppers that are mass-produced and made for a general audience, custom toppers make every cake stand out from the rest with their personalized touch.

These custom creations not only provide the opportunity to showcase individuality and creativity but also foster a sense of connection between the cake recipient and the giver. Custom toppers can include sentimental words, names, dates, numbers, or images that carry special meaning and create cherished memories.

How much do custom cake toppers cost?

The cost of custom cake toppers varies depending on several factors. These include the complexity of the design, the size of the topper, the material used, the level of detail, shipping or local pick-up options, and the specific design and artistry services needed. Some custom toppers may even cost less than you think as some cake topper makers offer basic or affordable options with simple designs, making them a more budget-friendly choice.

It is best to contact cake topper makers or visit their websites for accurate pricing. Remember to always ask for a price quote to ensure the topper fits your budget before placing an order. Keep in mind that higher quality materials and intricate designs usually have a higher price point, but also provide a more enduring and elegant cake topping experience.

Can custom cake toppers be shipped?

While most custom cake toppers can be shipped, the shipping details and costs depend on the specific arrangements made with the manufacturer or service provider. Generally, it is best to request for a shipping quote to determine if and how the topper can be shipped to your location. Shipping policies can vary from company to company, so always double-check these details to avoid any delivery concerns or additional fees.

Also, ensure that the product is shipped in a manner that protects its integrity and keeps it intact during transit. Some cake toppers might require special packaging or refrigeration to maintain their quality, so be aware of these specific requirements before placing an order to avoid receiving a damaged or unsuitable product.

What happens if I need to make a change or cancel my custom cake topper order?

Cancellation and change policies for custom cake toppers may vary depending on the location and the design stage. Some companies offer a set timeframe for making changes or cancellations, while others may consider requests on a case-by-case basis. It is advisable to inquire about the cancellation or amendment policy with the cake topper maker before placing an order.

In case of unforeseen circumstances or customer dissatisfaction, it is likely that adjustments can be made if the order hasn’t been dispatched yet or if it is at an early stage of completion. However, it is essential to promptly discuss your concerns or issues with the manufacturer to explore the available options and find the best resolution.

As an Amazon Affiliate™ we receive compensation through qualified purchases at no cost to you!

--

--